Subway Share: Restaurant Subway Visit Website Request Info 26 Thompson Square Mall Monticello, NY 12701 (845) 453-1148 (845) 794-0550 (845) 794-9018 (fax) Facebook Hours: Monday thru Friday8 am to 9 pmSaturday9 am to 9 pmSunday9 am to 8 pm About Map About Now open!!! New look of subway and 1st location of NEW YORK STATE. Everyone most welcome.. What's Nearby? Distance: 5 10 15 20 25 50 mi.