STORY'S NEVERSINK PLANT CO. Share: Nursery STORY'S NEVERSINK PLANT CO. Visit Website Request Info 134 Mutton Hill Rd. NEVERSINK, New York 12765 (845) 985-5071 About Map About Greenhouse & Gardens - Offering rare succulents and interesting plants - houseplants, perennials, vegetables, patio pots. Garden Consultations and Contract Growing available. By Appointment Only. What's Nearby? Distance: 5 10 15 20 25 50 mi.